Judge's Assessment

Home
About us
Archive
Clubs
- Club Assessment by a Judge
- Club Assessment by a Lecturer
Events
Judges
Lecturers
Newsletters
- Newsletters
- Newsletter Archive (2015–2017)
PAGB

Judge's Assessment Form (Feedback About a Judge by a Club)

Judge feedback by clubs is extremely valuable to us so please complete this form to send us your feedback about every N&EMPF judge who judges at your club. Ideally, we recommend that you base your feedback on the views of 2 or 3 experienced people who can provide objective and thoughtful comments.

* Indicates required field

Club name *

Judge name *

Date of visit *

Type of competition (choose one) *

Club Heat Club Annual Exhibition Inter-Club Other

Event style (choose one) *

In Person Zoom Hybrid (i.e. combined In Person and Zoom)

Zoom is most commonly used by clubs but Zoom or Hybrid should be selected even where an alternative was used.

Media (you can choose several) *

PDI Print Panels AV Other

Topic (you can choose several) *

Open Nature Monochrome Theme

Total number of images judged (PDI/Prints only) *

Was a preview of the images offered to the judge in advance of the event? *

Yes No

ABOUT THE JUDGE

Punctuality *

Poor Satisfactory Excellent

Friendly & approachable *

Poor Satisfactory Excellent

Worked to the agreed timings *

Poor Satisfactory Excellent

Conveyed confidence & engaged the audience *

Poor Satisfactory Excellent

THE JUDGING PROCESS
Please assess the following skills and knowledge.

Communication and critiquing skills
A good judge is positive and constructive and speaks confidently using a variety of clear and expressive language.
Competition entrants should feel recognised and encouraged.
Comments and marks should be consistent and pace of delivery appropriate.

Communication & critiquing skills overall rating *

Poor Satisfactory Excellent

Photographic understanding
A good judge demonstrates sound knowledge and appreciation of all aspects of camera craft and technical skill, including the editing process.
They may make constructive suggestions for improvement where appropriate.

Photographic understanding overall rating *

Poor Satisfactory Excellent

Aesthetic understanding
A good judge should have the ability to appreciate images for more than merely the techniques involved.
They should demonstrate an appreciation of empathy, creativity and artistic intent where appropriate.
They should also demonstrate an appreciation of the role that impact, interest, visual awareness and communication play in the photography presented.

Aesthetic understanding overall rating *

Poor Satisfactory Excellent

Would you be happy to have this judge again? *

Yes No Unsure

Please give an overall comment noting any strengths and possible areas for improvement.
Respectful, constructive comments are always appreciated in assisting us in the development of our judging process.

Overall Comments *

DETAILS OF PERSON(S) SUBMITTING FORM

Name *

Position in club *

Date *

Email *

When you click submit, your feedback will be submitted to Carol McNiven Young, the Judges and Lecturers Secretary.

Thank you for taking the time to complete this form and helping N&EMPF improve the standards provided to clubs. Please continue to complete one of these forms every time you have a judge at your club.

Submit

CONTACT DETAILS

President
Sue Wilson DPAGB BPE3

Hon. General Secretary
Carol Cheetham CPAGB, APAGB
01283 812964

Website Enquiries
Steffan Nicholson
07710 116620